top of page

Rate Buydown vs Price Reduction: I Checked the Math So You Don't Have To

Writer: Brian Watters
Brian Watters
Nov 3
10 min read
Hands at a kitchen table with a calculator, pen, and real estate purchase paperwork as a buyer goes over the numbers on a home

I saw a post the other day that stopped me cold. The claim went like this: ask for $25,000 off an $800,000 house and your payment drops about $135 a month. But use that same $25,000 to buy down your rate and you'll save around $870 a month.


Sounds amazing. So I did what I always do. I ran the numbers myself, and then I ran them past my lender. The rate buydown vs price reduction question is a real one, and it deserves a real answer. Spoiler: on a permanent buydown, it's not $870. Not even close. There is one way to get near that number, and it comes with a catch nobody tells you about. I'll get to that.


First, What's a Rate Buydown?


A rate buydown means paying money up front, at closing, to get a lower interest rate for the life of the loan. That money is paid in "points." One point costs 1% of the loan amount. Not the price of the house. The loan.


How much does a point buy? My lender tells me that right now, in most cases, it takes somewhere around 0.75 to 1 point to drop your rate by a quarter percent (0.25%), across loan types. He was quick to add that this changes constantly, because rate pricing is set by the secondary market. So treat that as a fall 2026 ballpark, not a promise. Your lender gives you the real pricing on the day you lock.


Who pays for the points? It can be you, or it can be the seller, as a concession in your offer. That's where the $25,000 question comes in. When a seller is willing to give up $25,000, you can take it as a lower price, or you can ask for it as a credit toward buying down your rate.


Rate Buydown vs Price Reduction: The Real Numbers


One ground rule before the numbers: everything in this section is principal and interest only. Taxes, insurance, and the rest come later, and they matter.


Here's the setup. I'm using the same $800,000 house from that post, with 20% down. That's a $640,000 loan at 7.25% on a 30-year fixed. Principal and interest comes to about $4,366 a month.


Option 1: Take $25,000 off the price. Your price drops to $775,000 and your loan drops to $620,000. Principal and interest goes to about $4,229. That's roughly $136 a month saved. So that part of the post checks out.


Option 2: Use the $25,000 to buy down the rate. On a $640,000 loan, $25,000 buys about 3.9 points. If my lender's pricing held that steady all the way down, that would take your rate from 7.25% to somewhere between about 6.27% and 5.95%. On a buydown this big, pricing often doesn't hold that steady, so treat these as estimates using my lender's range, not a quote. The real savings could come in lower. Principal and interest saved: roughly $416 to $550 a month.


Even on those numbers, $416 to $550. Not $870.


To actually save $870 a month on this loan, you'd need a permanent rate around 5.15%. That's a drop of more than two full percentage points in your interest rate. $25,000 in points doesn't buy that.


I ran a smaller version too, because it's a common ask. Buying 7.25% down to 6.5% on that same $640,000 loan takes roughly $14,400 to $19,200 in points. It saves about $321 a month.

How sure am I? The principal-and-interest math is exact for those inputs. The point pricing is my lender's current range for a quarter-percent drop, stretched across almost four points, so treat the buydown savings as an estimate until your lender prices your actual loan.


And I don't know which kind of buydown that post was talking about. On a permanent buydown, on the numbers they gave, it doesn't hold up. But a temporary buydown can get close to $870 for one year. That's the catch, and I'll walk through it below.


Which One Actually Wins?


Single-story ranch home with pale green stucco, a two-car garage, a front lawn, and a mature shade tree in the Antelope Valley, the kind of purchase where a buyer weighs a rate buydown against a lower price
Photo by Brian Watters

Here's where I'm going to be fair, because the honest answer isn't "the buydown is a scam." On the monthly payment, the buydown still saves you more. At those estimated rates, $416 to $550 beats $136.


But the monthly payment isn't the only thing that matters. It depends on one question: how long are you going to keep this loan?


The price reduction gives you a few things the buydown doesn't:


  • A smaller loan balance. You owe $20,000 less from day one.


  • Lower property taxes. In California, your property tax is generally based on your purchase price. $25,000 off the price takes very roughly $25 to $30 a month off your tax bill, depending on the parcel. That's approximate, and special assessments vary a lot out here, so check the actual parcel.


  • Less cash at closing. With 20% down, a $25,000 lower price means $5,000 less down payment.


  • It sticks. If you refinance or sell, a buydown's benefit is gone. You paid for a rate you don't have anymore. A lower price and a smaller balance stay yours.


So I lined the two up over time using the same house and starting numbers, counting the payments, what you'd still owe, the $5,000 of down payment the price cut keeps in your pocket, and the estimated tax difference. Here's roughly where it landed:


  • At 2 years: the price cut is ahead by about $12,000 to $16,000.


  • At 5 years: close to a wash. Anywhere from the price cut about $2,000 ahead to the buydown about $8,000 ahead.


  • At 7 years: the buydown is ahead by about $7,000 to $22,000.


The buydown pulls ahead somewhere around four to five and a half years, and keeps gaining after that. That's my rough math using the estimated buydown pricing above, and it assumes you don't refinance or sell along the way. If the points price worse, the buydown takes longer to catch up. Not a guarantee.


So:

  • Planning to refinance in a couple of years, or not sure you'll stay? The price reduction is probably the better deal.


  • Planning to keep the loan a long time? The buydown can win.


The Break-Even Test (and Why My Lender Wants It Short)


If you only take one thing from this post, take this: figure out how long it takes for the buydown to pay for itself. Divide what the points cost by what they save you each month. That's your break-even.


On my example, $25,000 to save $416 to $550 a month is a break-even of about four to five years. The $14,400 to $19,200 version to get to 6.5% lands in the same range.


One catch: that's the simple test, points versus no points. Against a price cut, the buydown also has to beat the $136 a month the price cut already saves you, so the head-to-head takes longer. That's the four-to-five-and-a-half-year crossover from above.


My lender aims for a break-even of two years or less. He's seen buydowns that take more than six years to pay off, and he doesn't think those are a good idea. By his test, the buydowns in my example don't make the cut. That doesn't mean a buydown never makes sense. It means you should see the break-even in writing before you decide.


Marry the House, Date the Rate (The Catch With Buydowns)


You've probably heard the saying. Marry the house, date the rate. If rates come down later, you refinance.


But here's the catch nobody mentions when they're selling you on a buydown. Refinance in year two of a five-year break-even and you walked away from most of what you paid for. If you expect to refinance soon, buying down a rate you're planning to get rid of doesn't make a lot of sense.


And this is just my opinion, not a prediction you should bank on: nobody knows for sure where rates are going. My lender put it well. Nobody knows the future, but a good lender should understand what's pushing rates around and be able to tell you whether a buydown makes sense for you. Make the decision that works whether rates drop or not.


The Catch Nobody Told You: The 2-1 Temporary Buydown


You'll hear about these a lot, especially from builders. A 2-1 buydown lowers your payment as if your rate were 2% lower in year one and 1% lower in year two. Then it goes back to your full rate in year three.


Run that on the same $640,000 loan at 7.25%, and year one drops your principal and interest by about $832 a month. Year two, about $425. That's pretty close to the $870 from that post. So if that's what they meant, the number isn't crazy.


Here's the catch. That's year one. Year two is about half that, and in year three you're back to the full $4,366 for the next 28 years. Funding it takes roughly $15,000 of the seller's money. Lenders calculate the exact amount, so ask yours.


So my question is this: why would you use that kind of money to lower your payment for a year or two, when it could come off the price and stay with you?


Here's what most people miss. With a temporary buydown, your rate never actually changes. The seller's credit goes into an account that covers the difference in your payment for those first two years. You're still charged the full interest rate the whole time. Your lender will also generally qualify you at the full rate, not the teaser payment, so ask how your loan handles it.


Think about what that means. The seller's money goes into an account, and the account pays the difference on your payment. You "save" about $15,000 over two years because about $15,000 got spent covering it. Dollar for dollar, it's a wash. And your lender qualified you at the full payment anyway. In year three, that's the number you're living with. So why not just make your actual payment from day one, and put that money somewhere it stays with you, like off the price or toward a permanent buydown?


My lender prefers a permanent buydown over a temporary one, and his reasoning is worth hearing. A permanent buydown actually lowers your rate and the interest you pay. A temporary one just uses the seller's credit to subsidize your payment for a while. And his view is that if a seller is willing to give you a $20,000 credit, they'd probably take $20,000 off the price instead. So in his eyes, you're really the one paying for that temporary buydown.


That's his opinion, and it's a strong one. A 2-1 can still help a buyer who needs breathing room in the first couple of years. Just go in knowing what it is: a short-term payment break, not a lower rate.


How Much Can a Seller Actually Give You?


Here's something people mix up. A seller can take as much off the price as they're willing to. There's no loan-program cap on a price reduction. Credits are different. Money a seller puts toward your closing costs or points is capped by your loan type, and that cap covers other "interested parties" in the deal too. Here's the general picture for credits as of October 2026:


  • FHA: up to 6% of the sales price, toward closing costs, prepaid items, and discount points. Permanent and temporary buydowns count inside that 6%.


  • VA: the seller can pay your normal closing costs, plus up to 4% of the home's VA-appraised value in extra "concessions." A seller-paid temporary buydown counts toward that 4%. One wrinkle: because the 4% is based on the appraised value, a low appraisal shrinks it.


  • Conventional (primary home or second home): it depends on your down payment.

    • Less than 10% down: 3%

    • 10% to under 25% down: 6%

    • 25% or more down: 9%


  • Conventional (investment property): 2%


  • USDA: up to 6% of the sales price. Under USDA's current policy, a seller paying the buyer's agent commission doesn't count against that 6%.


A couple of things apply across the board. Credits generally can't be more than your actual costs, and they generally can't go toward your down payment. On conventional loans, the percentage is generally figured on the lower of the price or the appraised value. And lenders can add their own stricter rules on top.


So before you ask for a $25,000 credit, make sure your loan can actually use it. On my $800,000 example with 20% down, the conventional cap is 6%, so $25,000 fits. With 5% down, the cap would be 3%, or $24,000. Close, but it wouldn't. That's one more thing the price cut has going for it: if a credit won't fit under your cap, a price cut can.


These limits change from time to time, so check the current numbers with your lender before you write the offer.


What My Lender Says


I ran all of this past my lender, Rob Breiner, before publishing. Here's what he wanted buyers to hear, in my words:


  • Point pricing moves constantly. Around 0.75 to 1 point per quarter percent is typical right now, but it changes with the market.


  • Know your break-even. He aims for two years or less and won't push a buydown that takes six-plus years to pay back.


  • Permanent beats temporary in his book, for the reasons above.


  • It's not the same answer for everybody. The right call depends on your loan, how long you'll keep it, and where rates look like they're heading.


Don't Forget the Rest of the Payment


Everything above is principal and interest only. Your real monthly payment also includes property taxes, homeowners insurance, mortgage insurance if you put less than 20% down, and HOA dues if there are any. A buydown lowers your rate. It doesn't touch your taxes or your insurance.


If you haven't read it, here's my breakdown of what your payment will actually be, all-in. And if you want to see how much the rate moves your payment across a range of rates, I've got that too.


The Bottom Line


Is a buydown worth it? Sometimes. Is a $25,000 permanent buydown going to save you $870 a month? Not with the pricing I was given. A temporary one can get close in year one, but it doesn't last. A number that sounds too good is worth checking before you write an offer around it.


Here's how I'd think about it:


  1. Get the real point pricing from your lender, not a rule of thumb from social media. Not even from me.


  2. Figure out your break-even, and make sure it lands well before you expect to sell or refinance. My lender likes two years or less.


  3. Be honest with yourself about how long you'll keep the loan.


  4. Make sure your loan type can actually use the credit you're asking for.


  5. Look at the whole payment, not just the rate.


And remember, your lender's max isn't your budget. Where the payment lands for you is what matters.


I'm not perfect, and my numbers are a starting point, not a quote. But I'd rather walk you through the real math than let you write an offer based on a number that was never real. If you want to sit down and run this for a specific house, let's do it together.


Thanks to Rob Breiner NMLS 1199942 of Click Mortgage NMLS 284021

for walking me through the lender side of this.





Brian Watters, Realtor | ByOurRep.com | DRE 01748905 | Realty Executives Platinum

(661) 400-3990 | Brian@ByOurRep.com


This post is general education, not a loan quote or financial advice. The figures are example principal-and-interest calculations. Point pricing, rates, loan terms, and seller-contribution limits vary by lender, loan type, and the day you lock, and program rules change. Talk with your lender for real numbers, and with a tax professional about whether points are deductible for you.

bottom of page